The English Progressive and the Finnish Partitive as Predicate Modifiers: A New Solution to the Imperfective Paradox
نویسنده
چکیده
In this article I want to present a new approach to the semantics of the English progressive and show how the same ideas can also be applied to the semantics of the Finnish partitive case. In nearly all formal semantical theories of the progressive I am familiar with the progressive is formalized with the aid of a sentential operator. I suggest that if we formalize the progressive as a predicate modifier instead, we can solve many of the problems that have plagued previous theories of the progressive. I will start from Dowty’s classic theory of the progressive, show what defects have been found in it and show how it can be corrected.
منابع مشابه
Temporal Reference Frames and the Imperfective Paradox
This paper brings new evidence to bear on the topic of the Imperfective Paradox – a semantic puzzle involving tense-aspectual categories that lack completion entailments. The lack of completion entailments is usually associated with the so-called progressive and conative readings, illustrated in the Russian sentences in (1) and (2) respectively. In these examples, the matrix event described by ...
متن کاملThe Progressive and the Imperfective Paradox the Eventual Outcome Strategy 1 the Motivation for the Eventual Outcome Strategy 3 Dowty's Formulation of the Eventual Outcome Strategy
Formal semantics constitutes the framework of the research presented here, and the aim is to provide a solution to the imperfective paradox; i.e. explain why \Max was running" entails \Max ran", but \Max was running home" does not entail \Max ran home". This paper is divided into two parts. In Part I we evaluate what I will call the Eventual Outcome Strategy for solving the imperfective paradox...
متن کاملThe Progressive and the Imperfective
Formal semantics constitutes the framework of the research presented here, and the aim is to provide a solution to the imperfective paradox; i.e. explain why \Max was running" entails \Max ran", but \Max was running home" does not entail \Max ran home". This paper is divided into two parts. In Part I we evaluate what I will call the Eventual Outcome Strategy for solving the imperfective paradox...
متن کاملContrastive Analysis of Aspectual Oppositions in English and Persian
This article aims at contrasting aspectual oppositions in English and Persian in the context of the novel The Old Man and the Sea, and its translation by Daryabandari (1983) as the data. Unlike English, in Persian perfective and imperfective forms are morphologically marked. While the vast majority of English simple past forms are translated into Persian by past perfective forms, only less than...
متن کاملA developmental perspective on the Imperfective Paradox.
Imperfective or progressive verb morphology makes it possible to use the name of a whole event to refer to an activity that is clearly not a complete instance of that event, leading to what is known as the Imperfective Paradox. For example, a sentence like 'John was building a house' does not entail that a house ever got built. The Imperfective Paradox has received a number of different treatme...
متن کامل